You first need to know that this is the view of a 46-year old and a person who has played golf since eight years old. I am a bit of a traditionalist and for the players that know me I am often 10-20 years behind when it comes to technology. It took me years to move from persimmon woods to metal. I was only recently using a Taylor Made Burner Bubble 3-wood that was about 20 years old and sometimes a vintage older than the players I was competing against. Yes, the Titleist 3-wood that I acquired just over a year ago to replace is better, but not by much. You still need a good swing. This brings me to bully putters...chest putters, or however they are called. It’s about the swing.
I have always thought it was fundamentally wrong to anchor a club to the body. I perceived it as an unfair advantage when the pressure was on. How it has been within the rules of golf for so long since tried quite a number of years ago I also thought was fundamentally wrong. We have a small generation of golfers who have learned to play that way. We also have a considerable number of players who, whether through the dreaded yips or just down right weren't putting well and needed to re-focus, reached for the belly putter. This latter group will manage back to the traditional way of golfing I hope fairly well. Before these long putter shafts came into existence, those folks will again have to go back to the process of taping the grip or pulling out a different putter, or buying a new putter, to get out of that putting funk. Or they just play through it knowing it will pass. You can tell...I’ve been there, done that. It’s the former group, the relatively new players to the game of golf that lose out a bit more. They will have to learn to putt a different way for the first time. Is it a drastic change? No, it is after all a pendulum issue. Take the putter back, and then let it go forward to hit the ball. The mechanics of that has now shifted to the arms only and not part of the body. It will be a slight adjustment.
Have I ever used a belly putter? No. Over my 35 years of competitive golf I have seen every player, including really good players, go through putting woes and get really frustrated. To the point of almost quitting the game. Some have taken an extended break and come back reinvigorated. But just as putting issues can exist for days or weeks, it can also happen in one round of golf. Ever had a round going really well, then have a short putt on the 13th hole, miss it, and have those dreaded thoughts creep in to then go in the opposite direction for the last five holes? I think we can all put our hand up for that one.
Indeed, it is the psychology of golf and mind over matter. Not just about who can swing better but also who can manage their minds better. I have seen tremendous golfers on the range turn into mediocre players on the golf course, and vice versa. Mental toughness is a big part of this game. With this in mind, pardon the pun, let’s go back to the way the game of golf was intended to be played and train our minds to “swing” with the flow. The governing rules folks decided the new rules would take three years to take full effect. With respect that’s a mistake. It should have been one year – one golf season.
There’s debate out there if anchored putters are even an advantage at all. If it was, why are more people not using them and more anchor putters winning more? Good question though swinging with equipment anchored to your body seems out of place in this game. Another point is golf needs to adapt to keep people playing golf. Advancements in equipment and golf balls have certainly helped. The sweet spot on the golf club is much bigger today than the 1980s. The slow decline in golf participation has happened over the same time anchor putters have been in place. There are bigger issues to deal with.
To the players that will be out on the golf course over the next three years with the belly putters, you are playing by the rules and I respect and honour that. However, also know 2016 is coming. All the best during the transition process.